• ポートフォリオ機能


ポートフォリオを新規に作成して保存
既存のポートフォリオに追加保存

  • この表をプリントする
PDF PDFをダウンロード
審決分類 審判 査定不服 称呼類似 取り消して登録 X9122835
審判 査定不服 商3条柱書 業務尾記載 取り消して登録 X9122835
審判 査定不服 観念類似 取り消して登録 X9122835
審判 査定不服 外観類似 取り消して登録 X9122835
審判 査定不服 商6条一商標一出願 取り消して登録 X9122835
管理番号 1296256 
審判番号 不服2013-650046 
総通号数 182 
発行国 日本国特許庁(JP) 
公報種別 商標審決公報 
発行日 2015-02-27 
種別 拒絶査定不服の審決 
審判請求日 2013-07-24 
確定日 2014-11-12 
事件の表示 国際登録第1093688号に係る国際商標登録出願の拒絶査定に対する審判事件について、次のとおり審決する。 
結論 原査定を取り消す。 本願商標は、登録すべきものとする。
理由 1 本願商標
本願商標は、別掲1のとおりの構成からなり、第9類、第12類、第28類及び第35類に属する、日本国を指定する国際登録において指定された商品及び役務を指定商品及び指定役務として、2010年4月8日にItalyにおいてした商標登録出願に基づいてパリ条約第4条による優先権を主張し、2010年(平成22年)8月30日に国際商標登録出願されたものである。
その後、指定商品及び指定役務については、原審における、平成24年8月17日付けの手続補正書並びに当審における2013年6月13日付け及び2014年6月12日付けで国際登録簿に記載された限定の通報があった結果、最終的に別掲2のとおりの指定商品及び指定役務になったものである。
2 原査定の拒絶理由の要点
原査定は、以下の(1)ないし(3)のとおり認定、判断し、本願を拒絶したものである。
(1)本願は、その指定商品中に、商品の内容及び範囲を明確に指定したとは認められない表示を含むものであるから、商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備しない。
(2)本願は、第9類及び第12類において広範な範囲にわたる商品を指定しているため、このような状況の下では、出願人が本願商標をそれらの指定商品の全てについて使用しているか又は近い将来使用をすることについて疑義があるから、本願商標は、商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備しない。
(3)本願商標は、登録第2043876号商標、登録第4360578号-2号商標及び登録第4932133号商標(以下、これらをまとめて「引用商標」という。)と同一又は類似の商標であって、その商標に係る指定商品と同一又は類似の商標について使用をするものであるから、商標法第4条第1項第11号に該当する。
ア 登録第2043876号商標は、「GTO」の欧文字を横書きしてなり、昭和60年7月2日に登録出願、第12類に属する商標登録原簿に記載のとおりの商品を指定商品として、同63年4月26日に設定登録され、その後、2回にわたる商標権の存続期間の更新登録のほか、平成20年7月16日に、指定商品を第12類「船舶並びにその部品及び附属品(「エアクッション艇」を除く。),エアクッション艇,航空機並びにその部品及び附属品,鉄道車両並びにその部品及び附属品,自動車並びにその部品及び附属品,二輪自動車・自転車並びにそれらの部品及び附属品,乳母車,人力車,そり,手押し車,荷車,馬車,リヤカー,タイヤ又はチューブの修繕用ゴムはり付け片」とする指定商品の書換登録がされたものである。
イ 登録第4360578号-2号商標は、「GTO」の欧文字を標準文字で表してなり、平成11年5月24日に登録出願、同12年2月10日に設定登録された登録第4360578号商標の商標権の分割に係るものであって、第28類「遊戯用器具,囲碁用具,将棋用具,さいころ,すごろく,ダイスカップ,ダイヤモンドゲーム,チェス用具,チェッカー用具,手品用具,ドミノ用具,マージャン用具,ビリヤード用具,おもちゃ,人形,愛玩動物用おもちゃ」を指定商品として、同17年7月27日に分割移転の登録がされたものである。
ウ 登録第4932133号商標は、「GTO」の欧文字を標準文字で表してなり、平成17年8月5日に登録出願、第9類「回胴式遊技機,家庭用テレビゲーム用のプログラムを記憶させた記録媒体,家庭用テレビゲーム用のプログラム,家庭用テレビゲームおもちゃ,携帯用液晶画面ゲームおもちゃ用のプログラムを記憶させた電子回路及びCD-ROM,スロットマシン」を指定商品として、同18年2月24日に設定登録されたものである。
3 当審の判断
(1)商標法第3条第1項柱書き及び同法第6条第1項該当性について
本願の指定商品及び指定役務については、前記1のとおり限定された結果、商品の内容及び範囲が明確なものとなり、また、出願人の商標の使用または使用の意思があることに疑義はなくなったものと認められる。
(2)商標法第4条第1項第11号該当性について
本願商標は、別掲1のとおり、白抜きの「599」の数字と白抜きの文字中に線を有するデザイン化された「GTO」の欧文字からなるところ、「599」の数字部分と「GTO」の欧文字部分は、やや異なるレタリングで表されているものの、両者は傾斜した白抜きのデザインが共通し、文字の大きさも同一であるから、商標全体として、看る者にまとまりよく一体的な印象を与えるものである。
また、本願商標の構成中の「599」の数字部分、及び、「グランツーリスモ(高速長距離用乗用車)として認定された車」程の意味合いを認識させる「GTO」の欧文字部分は、それ自体単独では自他商品役務の識別標識としての機能は弱いものといえるが、これらの文字は、デザイン化された特徴のある書体で表されており、普通に用いられる方法で表示する標章とはいえないものであるから、本願商標は、構成全体をもって、識別標識としての機能を発揮するものである。
そうすると、本願商標に係る構成においては、殊更、「GTO」の文字部分が着目され、取引に資されるというよりは、むしろ、構成全体を持って、その指定商品及び指定役務の出所を表示する商標として認識されるものとみるのが相当である。
してみれば、本願商標は、「ゴーキューキュージーティーオー」の称呼のみを生ずるものであって、単に「ジーティーオー」の称呼が生ずることはないものである。
以上のとおりであるから、本願商標から「ジーティーオー」の称呼をも生ずるとし、その上で、本願商標と引用商標とが「ジーティーオー」の称呼を共通にする類似の商標であるから、商標法第4条第1項第11号に該当するということはできない。
(3)まとめ
したがって、本願商標が商標法第3条第1項柱書き及び本願が同法第6条第1項の要件を具備しないとした拒絶理由は解消した。また、本願商標が同法第4条第1項第11号に該当するとした拒絶の理由は、妥当でなく、原査定は取消を免れない。
その他、本願について拒絶の理由を発見しない。
よって、結論のとおり審決する。
別掲 【別記】

別掲2(本願商標の指定商品及び指定役務)
第9類「Amusement apparatus and games adapted for use with television receivers and with an external display screen or monitor;apparatus for games adapted for use with television receivers and with an external display screen or monitor;video output game machines for use with television and with an external display screen or monitor;apparatus for consumer games adapted for use with television receivers and with an external display screen or monitor;video games for use with automatic or token-operated machines;controllers,joysticks,consoles,memory cards,volume controllers and mice for consumer video game machines adapted for use with television receivers and with an external display screen or monitor;electronic circuits and media-recorded programs for hand-held games with liquid crystal displays;electronic circuits and CD-ROMs recorded with programs for hand-held games with liquid crystal displays;computer game cartridges;video game cartridges;cartridges for electronic games;video game cassettes;cassettes for electronic games;computer game equipment in the nature of steering wheels for PCs with double gear-shifting systems;computer game equipment containing memory discs;computer game programs;recorded programs for electronic games;recorded computer software for video games to be used in connection with automatic and coin operated machines;programs for arcade video game machines;apparatus for arcade games adapted for use with television receivers and with an external display screen or monitor;earphones for use with hand-held games with liquid crystal displays;HI-FI stereo systems comprised of stereos,CD players,loudspeakers,audio speakers,liquid crystal display and headphones,television apparatus,liquid crystal display television apparatus,liquid crystal display screens,home theater systems comprised of speaker,cube subwoofers,DVD changers and audio-video home theater receivers,television cameras,radios,walkie-talkies,microphones,cordless telephones,telephones,telephone apparatus,telephone receivers,cellular phones,cellular phone covers,bags and cases adapted for cellular phones,leather holders for mobile phones,devices for hands-free use of mobile phones in cars,comprising hands-free holders,hands-free microphones,headsets,microphones and speakers;control units for navigation systems for vehicles,control units of central locking systems for vehicles;navigation apparatus for vehicles (on-board computers),satellite navigational apparatus,global positioning system (GPS) consisting of computers,computer software,transmitters,receivers,and network interface devices,computer hardware and software system for tracking people and objects using GPS data on a device on the tracked people and objects,vehicle radios,remote control apparatus,antennas,digital voice recorders,and other telecommunication devices and apparatus,downloadable images and character data of magazines,books,newspapers,maps,pictures and drawings,downloadable video images;downloadable electronic publications;pre-recorded video cassettes,CD-ROMs and DVD featuring car races and the history of automobile manufacturers;pre-recorded video cassettes,CD-ROMs and DVD featuring high-performance cars and automobiles;CD players;DVD players;MP3 players;electronic handheld units and accessories,namely personal digital assistants comprised of batteries,chargers,headsets,stands,cases,covers,holsters and docking stations for the wireless receipt,transmission,and storage of data,voice transmissions and email messages;battery chargers;bags and cases adapted for CD players,MP3 players,DVD players;leather MP3 holders;leather MP3 player holders;leather CD holders;leather CD player holders;leather DVD holders;leather DVD player holders;digital photo frames,digital cameras,digital video cameras,digital video projectors,bands,lanyards,slings and straps for carrying cellular phones and MP3 players,digital cameras and digital video cameras;lanyards especially adapted for holding cell phones,MP3 players,digital cameras,and digital video cameras;personal computers,portable computers,palmtop computers,laptop computers,computer screen savers software,mouse pads,computer mouse being data processing equipment,wrist rests for use with computer,desktop computers,notebook computers,computer keyboards,computer memories,tablet PCs,computer monitors,liquid crystal display computer monitors,recorded computer software,recorded computer operating programs,LAN magnetic and encoded cards for connecting portable computers to computer networks,memory cards and fax-modem cards for portable computers,printers for use with computers,modems,scanners,being data processing equipment,bags and cases adapted for computer batteries for notebook computers,bags and cases adapted for computers,leather computer holders;disk drives for computers,electronic personal organizers,electronic agendas,electronic organizers;electronic diaries,electronic language translators,electronic notice boards,electronic pens (visual display units),and other electronic machines,apparatus and their parts;computer software for automatic steering apparatus of vehicles;lasers not for medical purposes;credit card cases (not wallet);vehicle breakdown warning triangles;simulators for the steering and control of vehicles;vehicle drive training simulators.」
第12類
「Trucks,ambulances,racing motor cars,concrete mixing vehicles,sprinkling trucks,passenger cars (automobiles),amphibious vehicles,snowmobiles,trailers (vehicles),buses,fork lift trucks,motor cars,sports cars,convertible cars,cars,camping cars,casting cars,cycle cars,dining cars,dining cars (carriages),hand cars,ladle cars,lifting cars (lift cars),side cars,steeping cars,cars for cable transport installations,vans (vehicles),lorries,light lorries,electric vehicles,military vehicles for transport,refrigerated vehicles,remote control vehicles other than toys,water vehicles,caravans,dinner wagons (carriages),golf carts,goods handling carts,kick sledges,luggage trucks,motor buses,motor coaches,trolleys (vehicles),two-wheeled trolleys,waggons,refrigerated waggons (railroad vehicles),air bags (safety devices for automobiles and land vehicles),windscreens of automobiles and land vehicles,air pumps for automobiles and two-wheeled motor vehicles,clutches of automobiles and land vehicles,warning horns of automobiles and land vehicles,seats of automobiles and land vehicles,racing seats of automobiles and land vehicles,seat covers of automobiles and land vehicles,chassis of automobiles and land vehicles,bodies of automobiles and land vehicles,shaped covers for automobiles and land vehicles,wheels for automobiles and land vehicles,wheel spokes of automobiles and land vehicles,tires for automobiles and land vehicles,pneumatic tires for automobiles and land vehicles,inner tubes for pneumatic tires of automobiles and land vehicles,door handles of automobiles and land vehicles,doors of automobiles and land vehicles,mudguards for automobiles and land vehicles,luggage carriers of automobiles and land vehicles,rearview mirrors for automobiles and land vehicles,steering wheels of automobiles and land vehicles,covers for steering wheels of automobiles and land vehicles,bumpers for automobiles and land vehicles,windshields (windscreens) for automobiles and land vehicles,direction signals (turn signals) for automobiles and land vehicles,holding tops for automobiles and land vehicles,hoods for automobiles and land vehicles,window curtains of automobiles and land vehicles,spare wheel holders of automobiles and land vehicles,rims for wheels of automobiles and land vehicles,plated rims for wheels for automobiles and land vehicles,automobile roof racks,windscreen wipers for automobiles and land vehicles,power tailgates (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),tailboard lifts (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),elevating power tailgates (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),tipping apparatus (parts of trucks and waggons),tipping bodies for lorries (trucks),turn signals for automobiles and land vehicles,windows for automobiles and land vehicles,caps for petrol (gas) tanks for automobiles and land vehicles,hoods for land vehicle and automobile engines,land vehicle and automobile running boards,safety belts for land vehicle seats and for automobile seats,4-point safety belts for land vehicle seats and for automobile seats,undercarriages for automobiles and land vehicles,upholstery for automobiles and land vehicles,crankcases for components for motor cars (other than for engines),elevating tailgates (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),hubs for land vehicle and automobile wheels,spoke clips for wheels of automobiles and land vehicles,balance weights for land vehicle and automobile wheels,bands for wheel hubs of automobiles and land vehicles,studs for tires of automobiles and land vehicles,spikes for tires of automobiles and land vehicles,solid tires for land vehicle and automobile wheels,casings for pneumatic tires of automobiles and land vehicles,treads for retreading tires of automobiles and land vehicles,treads for land vehicles (roller belts),treads for vehicles (tractor type),valves for tires of automobiles and land vehicles,security harness for land vehicle and automobile seats,direction indicators for automobiles and land vehicles,openable sunroofs for automobiles and land vehicles,removable roofs for automobiles and land vehicles,sliding sunroofs for automobiles and land vehicles,tops for automobiles and land vehicles,removable tops for automobiles and land vehicles,soft holding tops for automobiles,convertible tops for automobiles and land vehicles,sun visors (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),ashtrays (parts of automobiles and land vehicles,included in this class),glass-holders (parts of automobiles and land vehicles,included in this class),dashboard drawers (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),dashboard hatches (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),glove compartments (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),glove boxes (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),covers for luggage trunks (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),door sill covers (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),ornamental strips (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),decorative strips (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),gear lever knobs coverings (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),carbon interior trims for automobiles (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),interior trimming details (parts of automobiles and land vehicles),parts for switch-off of air-bags for automobiles and land vehicles,non-skid devices for tires of automobiles and land vehicles,repair outfits for inner tubes of automobiles and land vehicles,anti-dazzle devices for automobiles and land vehicles,anti-glare devices for automobiles and land vehicles,anti-skid chains for automobiles and land vehicles,reversing alarms for automobiles and land vehicles,anti-theft devices for automobiles and land vehicles,sun-blinds adapted for automobiles and land vehicles,freewheels for automobiles and land vehicles,head-rests for seats of automobiles and land vehicles,armrests for seats of automobiles and land vehicles,luggage nets for automobiles and land vehicles,ski carriers for automobiles and land vehicles,sleeping berths for automobiles and land vehicles,trailer hitches for automobiles and land vehicles,windshield wipers for automobiles and land vehicles,safety seats for children for automobiles and land vehicles,safety,roll-bars for automobiles and land vehicles,anti-slipping devices for automobiles and land vehicles,anti-lock braking systems for automobiles and land vehicles,traction control systems for automobiles and land vehicles,namely traction engines,spoilers for automobiles and land vehicles,hands-free holders for telephones (parts of automobiles and land vehicles,included in this class),sets of spare wheels for automobiles and land vehicles,tractors,and other automobiles and land vehicles and their parts and fittings,gasoline engines for land vehicles,diesel engines for land vehicles,turbojet engines for land vehicles,traction engines for land vehicles,gas turbines for land vehicles,air turbines for land vehicles,steam turbines for land vehicles,hydraulic turbines for land vehicles and other non-electric prime movers for land vehicles (not including ”their parts”),driving motors for automobiles and land vehicles;transmission shafts for automobiles and land vehicles,axles for automobiles and land vehicles,spindles for automobiles and land vehicles;bearings for automobiles and land vehicles;power transmissions and gearings for automobiles and land vehicles,reduction gears for automobiles and land vehicles,hydraulic torque converters for automobiles and land vehicles,pneumatic shock absorbers for automobiles and land vehicles,suspension shock absorbers for automobiles and land vehicles,shock absorbing springs for automobiles and land vehicles,suspension springs for automobiles and land vehicles,spring shock absorbers for automobiles and land vehicles,cone brakes for automobiles and land vehicles,disc brakes for automobiles and land vehicles,block brakes for automobiles and land vehicles,and other brakes for automobiles and land vehicles,shaft couplings for automobiles and land vehicles,fluid couplings for automobiles and land vehicles and other machine elements for automobiles and land vehicles;propulsion mechanisms for automobiles and land vehicles,propellers shafts for automobiles and land vehicles,chains for automobiles and land vehicles,driving chains for automobiles and land vehicles,gear boxes for automobiles and land vehicles,gearing for automobiles and land vehicles,torsion bars for automobiles and land vehicles,transmission chains for automobiles and land vehicles,brake linings for automobiles and land vehicles,brake segments for automobiles and land vehicles,brake shoes for automobiles and land vehicles,connecting rods for automobiles and land vehicles (other than parts of motors and engines),hydraulic circuits for automobiles and land vehicles;AC motors or DC motors for automobiles and land vehicles (not including ”their parts”);electric motors for automobiles and land vehicles,motors for automobiles and land vehicles.」
第28類
「Apparatus for games other than those adapted for use with an external display screen or monitor,electronic games and amusement machines other than those adapted for use with television sets and with an external display screen or monitor,video games and hand held games (other than those adapted for use with television receivers only),coin or token-operated slot machines in shopping arcades not for use with television receivers,pocket video games,pocket-sized electronic games other than those designed to be used only with television sets,hand-held video games,hand-held video games with liquid crystal displays (other than those adapted for use with television receivers only),portable electronic games and toys,hand-held units for playing video games,stand alone video game machines other than those adapted for use with television receivers only,cartridges and disks for electronic games other than those adapted for use only with television receivers,coin or token-operated game machines used in stores and not for use with television sets and with an external display screen or monitor;toy building blocks,scale model vehicles,scale model cars,wood scale model cars,wood scale model vehicles,scale model classic cars,scale model classic vehicles,scale model racing cars,scale model racing vehicles,full-size car replicas for ornamental and entertainment purposes,full-size vehicle replicas for ornamental and entertainment purposes,full-size car replicas for sporting exhibitions,full-size vehicle replicas for sporting exhibitions,all being toys;toy modular construction sets and connecting links therefor,toy construction block kits,toy car construction block kits,toy vehicle construction block kits,construction sets made up of bars and spheres that can be linked magnetically to form three-dimensional structures,namely construction sets and building blocks (toys),toy vehicle trucks,toy vehicles,toy gasoline service stations,toy racing cars tracks,toy car garages,toy cubes featuring vintage black and white images of Ferrari’s story,toy plush steering wheels,wood pull along cars (toys),wood trucks with cars (toys),toy pedal karts for kids,ride-on toy cars,cars and go-karts for children in pedal version or working with batteries (toys);amusement machines and apparatus for use in amusement parks (other than arcade video game machines).」
第35類
「Retail services or wholesale services for automobiles and their parts and accessories;organization of exhibitions for commercial or advertising purposes,organization of trade fairs for commercial or advertising purposes;customer loyalty services for commercial promotional and/or advertising purposes;advertising,advertising of goods and services on the Internet and by means of mobile telephony services and by electronic mail,advertising agencies,advertising by mail order,direct mail advertising,layout services for advertising purposes,dissemination of advertising matter,modelling for advertising or sales promotion,on-line advertising on a computer network,outdoor advertising,publicity agencies,publicity columns preparation,publicity material rental,publication of publicity texts,radio advertising,radio commercials,rental of advertising time on communication media,television advertising,television commercials,updating of advertising material,writing of publicity texts,rental of advertising space,promotion of goods and services by preparing and organizing promotional contests and competitions with prizes to be won,on a global computer network and/or by means of mobile telephony services,promotion of goods and services by placing advertisements and advertising displays on an on-line electronic site accessible via a global computer network and/or by means of mobile telephony services,promotion of websites for third parties and other advertising and publicity;demonstration of goods,distribution of samples,commercial information and advice for consumers (consumer advice shop),presentation of goods on communication media for retail purposes,sales promotion for others.」
審決日 2014-10-30 
国際登録番号 1093688 
審決分類 T 1 8・ 263- WY (X9122835)
T 1 8・ 262- WY (X9122835)
T 1 8・ 18- WY (X9122835)
T 1 8・ 261- WY (X9122835)
T 1 8・ 91- WY (X9122835)
最終処分 成立  
前審関与審査官 今田 尊恵長澤 祥子 
特許庁審判長 井出 英一郎
特許庁審判官 内藤 順子
田中 亨子
商標の称呼 ゴキューキュージイテイオオ、ゴヒャクキュージューキュージイテイオオ、ジイテイオオ 
代理人 鮫島 睦 
代理人 勝見 元博 
代理人 寺田 花子 
代理人 田中 光雄 

プライバシーポリシー   セキュリティーポリシー   運営会社概要   サービスに関しての問い合わせ