• ポートフォリオ機能


ポートフォリオを新規に作成して保存
既存のポートフォリオに追加保存

  • この表をプリントする
PDF PDFをダウンロード
審決分類 審判 査定不服 商6条一商標一出願 取り消して登録 X0607091112243537404142
審判 査定不服 商3条柱書 業務尾記載 取り消して登録 X0607091112243537404142
管理番号 1280148 
審判番号 不服2012-650098 
総通号数 167 
発行国 日本国特許庁(JP) 
公報種別 商標審決公報 
発行日 2013-11-29 
種別 拒絶査定不服の審決 
審判請求日 2012-11-14 
確定日 2013-08-21 
事件の表示 国際登録第996056号に係る国際商標登録出願の拒絶査定に対する審判事件について,次のとおり審決する。 
結論 原査定を取り消す。 本願商標は,登録すべきものとする。
理由 1 本願商標
本願商標は,「FLSmidth」の欧文字を書してなり,第6類,第7類,第9類,第11類,第12類,第24類,第35類,第37類,第40類,第41類及び第42類に属する日本国を指定する国際登録において指定された商品及び役務を指定商品及び指定役務として,2008年5月6日にDenmarkにおいてした商標登録出願に基づくパリ条約第4条による優先権を主張し,2008年(平成20年)10月30日に国際商標登録出願されたものである。
その後,指定商品及び指定役務については,原審における平成22年8月9日付けの手続補正書及び当審における2013年(平成25年)5月31日付けで国際登録簿に記録された限定の通報により,最終的に,別掲のとおりにされたものである。
2 原査定の拒絶の理由の要点
(1)本願は,その指定商品及び指定役務中,第7類,第11類,第37類及び第42類において明確でない表示があり,その内容及び範囲を明確に指定したものとは認められない。したがって,本願は,商標法第6条第1項の要件を具備しない。
(2)本願商標は,その指定商品及び指定役務中,第6類,第11類及び第37類において,広範にわたる商品及び役務を指定しているため,出願人がそれらの指定商品及び指定役務について出願に係る商標を使用しているか又は近い将来使用をすることについて疑義があるといわざるを得ない。したがって,本願商標は,商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件を具備しない。
3 当審の判断
本願の指定商品及び指定役務については,前記1のとおり補正及び限定された結果,商品及び役務の内容及び範囲が明確なものになり,かつ,請求人が,その指定商品及び指定役務について本願商標の使用又は使用の意思があることについての疑義がなくなったものと認められる。
したがって,本願商標が商標法第3条第1項柱書の要件及び本願が同法第6条第1項の規定の要件を具備しないとして拒絶した原査定の拒絶の理由は,解消した。
その他,本願について拒絶の理由を発見しない。
よって,結論のとおり審決する。
別掲 第6類
Unwrought and partly wrought base metals and their alloys,including alloys for cement manufacture equipment;metal pipes,balls of steel;goods of base metals for use in the cement and minerals industries;metal building materials,buildings of metal,including engine rooms and buildings to store cement;metal containers for storing and/or transportation [excluding reservoir of metal];metal pins;metal belts to handle loads;parts and accessories for the above goods (not included in other classes).
第7類
Metalworking machines and tools and parts thereof;mining machines and apparatus and parts thereof;construction machines and apparatus and parts thereof;chemical processing machines and apparatus and parts thereof;pulp making,papermaking or paper-working machines and apparatus and parts thereof;engines not for land vehicles;gears and couplings (except for land vehicles),including gear and couplings for mills,wind mills,pumps,compressors and generators and gear and couplings for vessels;valves (machine parts);engines and apparatus for cement manufacture;engines for use in mines;conveyors and haulage apparatus for mining;mineral dressing apparatus,namely machines for use in the mineral industry;machines and apparatus for the cement industry,the mining industry and related industries (not included in other classes),mechanical diggers and excavators;cutters (machines);wet separation equipment (machines);cyclones (machines),namely separators for separation of minerals from liquid substances;purifiers for cleaning of machines of chemical processing machines and apparatus;ground surface finishing and compacting machines,namely,leveling rollers;conveyors (machines),including roller conveyors and elevator conveyors,conveyance systems;hoists for mining;loading ramps (machines);elevator platforms (machines),conveyor belts,including conveyor belts for liquid substances (machines);conveyance systems for materials,namely machines for mining and cement manufacture,including conveyor belts for horizontal conveyance,fixed and mobile conveyor belts,elevators for conveyance of raw materials,helical conveyors and pressure conveyors,cranes (hoists and lifting devices),including cranes for loading and unloading of ships,mechanical and pneumatic conveyors,pendulum conveyors;chain feeders (machines),feed belt conveyors,including apron feeder;sizing plants (machines),sizing machines for industrial use,vibrating screening plants and filtration plants and screening plants and filtration plants mounted with rolls or drums (machines);bearings (machine parts),fluid bed drying plants,namely machines for drying of raw materials;machines for use in the cement and minerals industries;presses (machines);centrifuges (machines);separators;flotation machines for use in wet separation of minerals from other materials;cutting machines;crushing machines;grinding machines and grinding plants;feeders for cement,minerals,metal working,mining,construction,chemical processing,pulp making,papermaking,paper-working,carburetor (parts of machines);fans for motors and engines;cranes (hoists and lifting devices);pumps (machines),membrane (not included in other classes) for pumps;dust removing installations for cleaning purposes;disintegrators,including raw mills,rolling mills,grinding mills [for chemical processing],ball grinders for metalworking;semi-autogenous mills,beater mills and mills for manufacture of cement and minerals;conductor pipes and liners (machine parts) for mills;grinding flanges (machine parts);axles for machines;blade sharpening [stropping] machines;belt mounted driving wheels (machine parts)(not for land vehicles);slides for machine elements,cutters (machine parts);plates for protection of machines for use in the cement and minerals industries;parts and accessories for all of the above products (not included in other classes).
第9類
Apparatus and instruments for scientific research in laboratories,including crucibles;geodetic apparatus and instruments;measuring or testing machines and instruments;apparatuses and instruments for conducting,switching,transforming,accumulating,regulating or controlling electricity;plotters (for curve drawing);computer software for process simulators in the cement and minerals industries;metal detectors for industrial purposes;dosimeters;scanners (data processing equipment);data processing equipment in the form of computer hardware and software (recorded),including computer systems for process control and automation,computer software for chemical analysis and control and adjustment of data for raw materials and manufactured materials,analysis apparatus,not for medical purposes;parts and accessories for the above products (not included in other classes).
第11類
Apparatus and equipment for heating,including rotary kilns and drying kilns;incinerators and burners,combustion furnaces;drying apparatus,namely apparatus for dehydration;parts and accessories (not included in other classes) for incinerators,including bearings,cylinders,rolls,drums and seal rings;drying apparatus;cooling installations and machines,cooling apparatus,including cooling apparatus for slag and stones;cooling containers;filters (parts of industrial installations for use in air pollution control);cleaning apparatus for all sorts of emissions,including exhaust smoke cleaning apparatus and exhaust gas cleaning apparatus and dust cleaning apparatus;gas suspension calcinators,namely machines for separation and neutralisation of gases,heating apparatus in the form of equipment for grilling,calcination and annealing,including limestone calcination equipment,preheater equipment and melting equipment;oxidation reactors (parts of machines for use in the cement manufacturing industry,mining,mineral processing,chemical and power industries),exhaust gas cleaning installations for power stations and industrial installations;heat-regulating apparatus (not included in other classes);heat exchangers (not included in other classes);ventilation installations,air conditioning installations;parts and accessories for the above products (not included in other classes).
第12類
Land vehicles for transportation by the cement and mineral industry,including tipper vehicles with release mechanisms,hopper-cars,mine cars,tipper wagons,tripper cars;maintenance cars for machines;launch lifts (parts for vessels for us on land);carts;parts and accessories for all of the above products (not included in other classes).
第24類
Filtering materials of textile.
第35類
Business investigations;information relating to business activities;sorting and editing information in computer databases;commercial project management for building projects.
第37類
Contracting business,namely supervision of building construction and building project management;installation;construction;construction of industrial plants,including turnkey and semi-turnkey plants;building and repair of warehouses for storing of cement,minerals and raw materials;installation,maintenance and repair of apparatus,equipment and machines for cement and mineral production;construction,installation,maintenance and repair of apparatus,equipment and machines for mining and mineral dressing installations;installation,maintenance and repair of incinerators and burners,cooling installations and machines,filters (parts of industrial installations),purifying plants for sewers and for waste water,water cleaning apparatus and machines,water filtering apparatus,combustion plants,air and/or gas filtering installations,waste gas cleaning installations for power stations,industrial installations and ventilation installations;installation,maintenance and repair of turnkey plants and process plants;installation,maintenance and repair of disintegrators,including raw mills and cement mills for manufacture of cement;maintenance and repair of plants and machines for the cement and mineral industries;mounting and start up of machines for manufacture of cement and mineral process installations;reconstruction and maintenance and repair of plants and machines for the cement and mineral industries;installation,maintenance and repair of computer hardware;installation,maintenance and repair of apparatus and instruments for weighing,measuring,luminous or mechanical signals,electro monitoring apparatus,and instruments for conducting,switching,transforming,accumulating,regulating or controlling electricity.
第40類
Manufacture and treatment of materials and objects,namely,processing of cement and minerals;destruction of waste and trash,incineration of waste and trash,recycling of waste and trash,waste treatment [transformation];air purification;filtering for hazardous substances in materials.
第41類
Education and training.
第42類
Scientific and technological research and development;computer software design;industrial design;industrial analysis and research,development and design;engineering;technical research management on civil engineering;testing of mining machines and apparatus;providing technical information;professional advisor y services (not commercial),namely technological advice on technical solutions,research and development in the field of technical research and materials testing and/or supervision of extraction of raw material,including raw material analyses for choice of process equipment and in the form of feasibility studies;technological advice on the management of turnkey plants and process installations;development and research in relation to cement industry,mining industry and related industries,including manufacture of cement,mining and protection of the environment;geological prospecting;geological investigations:architectural planning and architectural advice in connection with construction work;contracting business,namely technological planning of construction projects,including plan arrangements,planning of construction projects,foundation and construction work,project design of steel and concrete constructions,project design of process equipment and mounting of process equipment,project design of plants,construction,mounting,test and start up work of process installations;technological projecting and advice in connection with supply of turnkey and semi-turnkey cement plants,manufacture installations,plant sections,warehouse facilities,machines,spare parts and in connection with the supply of control and operating systems;inspection of cement manufacture installations;design of machines for manufacture of cement and mineral process installations;design and development of computer hardware and computer software;design of computer systems,adaptation,installation and updating of computer software;development and research in relation to the oil,gas and energy supply industry;scientific and technological project management in relation to construction projects.
審決日 2013-08-08 
国際登録番号 0996056 
審決分類 T 1 8・ 18- WY (X0607091112243537404142)
T 1 8・ 91- WY (X0607091112243537404142)
最終処分 成立 
前審関与審査官 田口 玲子清川 恵子八木橋 正雄薩摩 純一 
特許庁審判長 井出 英一郎
特許庁審判官 田中 亨子
谷村 浩幸
商標の称呼 エフエルスミス 
代理人 山本 秀策 
代理人 森下 夏樹 
  • この表をプリントする

プライバシーポリシー   セキュリティーポリシー   運営会社   サービスに関しての問い合わせ